Forum:Canon Issues

With the controversal statements by Louis Castle that Red Alert I having no conenction with Tiberium Dawn, I think its time to define who overrides what in canon. Since Westwood's FAQ and manuals stated that Red Aler 1 is a sequal to Tiberium Dawn, years before EA took over the franchise, the manual information overrides producer opinions. --Eldarone 19:21, 26 February 2008 (UTC)
 * Agreed. Shaur M. S. Grizlin 21:57, 26 February 2008 (UTC)


 * Indeed, I think we got it right with our canon. Starting with RA2 the universes are separate. But RA1 is kind of in between. Also in the RA universe you can never be certain what is real and what is not due to all the time machine experiments (look at RA3 for instance, the Psychic Dominator Disaster never happened) --Agaiz 10:10, 27 February 2008 (UTC)

Persenaly i dont think renegade should be connsidered as part of the canon becouse it was not made As a neutral game. the choice between nod and gdi should be up the player i dont wish to offend Annybody but renegade looks like gdi propoganda to me (there is no nod campaign)and it makes brotherhood look like criminals. the power of c&c is and allways should be a choice gdi or nod only the player should make this choice.not be put in a faction like a no choice game.at least that is my look on the matter!


 * Renegade IS canon. It isn't propaganda, although it does show the war from the perspective of a redneck, sorry, Nick Parker. The power of Renegade are the strings it contains (text files - there is an atrociously high amount of content in there) and the audio files as well as insight it provides (after ignoring stupidity like GDI soldiers looking like hastily formed militia or Nod storm troopers wearing red pajamas instead of proper camouflaged BDUs). Shaur M. S. Grizlin 17:28, 16 May 2008 (UTC)

ok that will do thank you! but what happens to the gdi soldiers that are around temple prime when gdi fires the ion canon? i mean the player dous not tetreat them so??? A.a. gretchko19:39 16 may 2008 (utc)
 * You mean TD, right? It isn't too accurate in this aspect, but I assume Solomon withdrawn them before ordering the strike. Shaur M. S. Grizlin 17:55, 16 May 2008 (UTC)

no i meant temple prime c&c 3 what happens to the gdi forces there?A.a. gretchko19:39 16 may 2008 (utc)
 * GDI goes boom. Shaur M. S. Grizlin 19:52, 16 May 2008 (UTC)

what happens during the gulf war? what weapons are used by gdi and iraq and how did it end?A.a. gretchko